Cyclical & Commodity Producers

Commodity and cyclical producers valued through the whole cycle (normalized free cash flow), not one boom or bust year.

Miners, drillers and other cyclicals swing wildly year to year. We value them on through-cycle earnings so a single peak or trough year doesn't distort the picture.
Clear
168 stocks · page 1 of 3
Educational use only — not investment advice. "Undervalued / fairly valued / overvalued" and every risk score reflect our models vs. price, which can be wrong or based on stale or incomplete data. Always review the company's own financials and SEC filings, and consult a licensed advisor, before acting.
NCLH
Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Ltd.
Undervalued
Industrials
Price$14.24
Model IV$18.19
P/IV1.01
Discount 22% Return to IV: +27.7%
Market implies +2.7%/yr vs model +8.0% · below model
HLLY
Holley Inc.
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$2.50
Model IV$2.71
P/IV1.01
Discount 8% Return to IV: +8.3%
Owner yield 17.3% 10-yr IRR 26.3% · steady
Market implies +0.3%/yr vs model +3.0% · in line
SMP
STANDARD MOTOR PRODUCTS, INC.
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$37.15
Model IV$38.54
P/IV1.02
Discount 4% Return to IV: +3.7%
Owner yield 6.7% 10-yr IRR 13.8% · moderate
Market implies +4.9%/yr vs model +8.0% · below model
NC
NACCO INDUSTRIES INC
Undervalued
Energy
Price$37.22
Model IV$49.16
P/IV1.03
Discount 24% Return to IV: +32.1%
Market implies +1.6%/yr vs model +8.0% · below model
APTV
Aptiv PLC
Deeply undervalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$43.57
Model IV$65.09
P/IV1.04
Discount 33% Return to IV: +49.4%
Owner yield 14.3% 10-yr IRR 26.4% · moderate
Market implies 0.0%/yr vs model +7.2% · below model
HCC
WARRIOR MET COAL, INC.
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$88.47
Model IV$90.09
P/IV1.05
Discount 2% Return to IV: +1.8%
Market implies +3.9%/yr vs model +5.0% · in line
ALK
ALASKA AIR GROUP, INC.
Fairly valued
Industrials
Price$41.90
Model IV$43.63
P/IV1.05
Discount 4% Return to IV: +4.1%
Owner yield 15.1% 10-yr IRR 28.1% · moderate
Market implies +5.9%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
ASIX
AdvanSix Inc.
Undervalued
Basic Materials
Price$16.25
Model IV$21.04
P/IV1.07
Discount 23% Return to IV: +29.5%
Owner yield 1.4% 10-yr IRR -11.1% · steady
Market implies -7.1%/yr vs model +0.0% · below model
THRM
Gentherm Inc
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$36.28
Model IV$32.52
P/IV1.07
Premium +12% Return to IV: -10.4%
Owner yield 5.3% 10-yr IRR 10.5% · moderate
Market implies +7.0%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
LEA
LEAR CORP
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$120.22
Model IV$134.04
P/IV1.07
Discount 10% Return to IV: +11.5%
Owner yield 8.9% 10-yr IRR 16.4% · steady
Market implies +3.2%/yr vs model +5.8% · in line
AR
ANTERO RESOURCES Corp
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$33.96
Model IV$33.27
P/IV1.07
Premium +2% Return to IV: -2.0%
Market implies -2.9%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
IIIN
INSTEEL INDUSTRIES INC
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$29.83
Model IV$25.25
P/IV1.09
Premium +18% Return to IV: -15.4%
Owner yield 9.7% 10-yr IRR 15.6% · steady
Market implies +4.1%/yr vs model +3.1% · in line
COP
CONOCOPHILLIPS
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$127.53
Model IV$125.86
P/IV1.09
Premium +1% Return to IV: -1.3%
Owner yield 5.6% 10-yr IRR 9.5% · steady
Market implies +4.9%/yr vs model +5.8% · in line
TX
Ternium S.A.
Fairly valued
Basic Materials
Price$56.84
Model IV$52.87
P/IV1.10
Premium +8% Return to IV: -7.0%
Owner yield 2.3% 10-yr IRR -5.1% · steady
Market implies +1.7%/yr vs model +1.0% · in line
IOSP
INNOSPEC INC.
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$92.56
Model IV$75.22
P/IV1.10
Premium +23% Return to IV: -18.7%
Market implies +6.7%/yr vs model +4.7% · in line
THO
THOR INDUSTRIES INC
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$69.94
Model IV$71.70
P/IV1.10
Discount 2% Return to IV: +2.5%
Owner yield 14.6% 10-yr IRR 20.0% · steady
Market implies -2.1%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
ACNT
ASCENT INDUSTRIES CO.
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$14.58
Model IV$12.11
P/IV1.12
Premium +20% Return to IV: -16.9%
Owner yield 7.5% 10-yr IRR 9.0% · steady
Market implies -2.4%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
EQT
EQT Corp
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$50.13
Model IV$48.89
P/IV1.12
Premium +3% Return to IV: -2.5%
Owner yield 4.9% 10-yr IRR 7.5% · steady
Market implies +4.8%/yr vs model +5.5% · in line
GEL
GENESIS ENERGY LP
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$15.03
Model IV$13.32
P/IV1.13
Premium +13% Return to IV: -11.4%
Market implies -2.5%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
MTX
MINERALS TECHNOLOGIES INC
Fairly valued
Basic Materials
Price$66.67
Model IV$65.95
P/IV1.17
Premium +1% Return to IV: -1.1%
Owner yield 6.0% 10-yr IRR 8.5% · steady
Market implies +3.1%/yr vs model +3.4% · in line
AXTA
Axalta Coating Systems Ltd.
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$31.86
Model IV$26.35
P/IV1.17
Premium +21% Return to IV: -17.3%
Owner yield 6.4% 10-yr IRR 10.0% · steady
Market implies +6.2%/yr vs model +4.1% · in line
FUN
Six Flags Entertainment Corporation/NEW
Deeply undervalued
Communication Services
Price$12.37
Model IV$17.91
P/IV1.17
Discount 31% Return to IV: +44.8%
Market implies +0.9%/yr vs model +8.0% · below model
JBLU
JETBLUE AIRWAYS CORP
Fairly valued
Industrials
Price$4.57
Model IV$4.60
P/IV1.19
Discount 1% Return to IV: +0.7%
Market implies +6.4%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
PCAR
PACCAR INC
Overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$114.73
Model IV$97.59
P/IV1.19
Premium +18% Return to IV: -14.9%
Owner yield 6.0% 10-yr IRR 10.5% · steady
Market implies +7.0%/yr vs model +5.8% · in line
ROCK
GIBRALTAR INDUSTRIES, INC.
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$41.72
Model IV$32.29
P/IV1.20
Premium +29% Return to IV: -22.6%
Owner yield 12.9% 10-yr IRR 17.6% · steady
Market implies +1.3%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
LMT
LOCKHEED MARTIN CORP
Overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$535.40
Model IV$442.64
P/IV1.21
Premium +21% Return to IV: -17.3%
Owner yield 4.7% 10-yr IRR 6.0% · steady
Market implies +6.2%/yr vs model +4.4% · in line
NL
NL INDUSTRIES INC
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$6.83
Model IV$5.01
P/IV1.21
Premium +36% Return to IV: -26.7%
Owner yield 2.0% 10-yr IRR -4.9% · steady
Market implies +5.1%/yr vs model +3.6% · in line
NX
Quanex Building Products CORP
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$20.10
Model IV$15.34
P/IV1.21
Premium +31% Return to IV: -23.7%
Owner yield 9.5% 10-yr IRR 19.4% · moderate
Market implies +9.5%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
AESI
Atlas Energy Solutions Inc.
Fairly valued
Energy
Price$13.27
Model IV$13.72
P/IV1.22
Discount 3% Return to IV: +3.4%
Market implies +6.0%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
LXU
LSB INDUSTRIES, INC.
Fairly valued
Basic Materials
Price$10.44
Model IV$10.20
P/IV1.23
Premium +2% Return to IV: -2.3%
Owner yield 3.6% 10-yr IRR 1.9% · steady
Market implies +2.2%/yr vs model +3.3% · in line
E
ENI SPA
Overvalued
Energy
Price$54.04
Model IV$44.25
P/IV1.27
Premium +22% Return to IV: -18.1%
Owner yield 7.0% 10-yr IRR 9.4% · steady
Market implies +4.2%/yr vs model +1.6% · in line
ECVT
Ecovyst Inc.
Fairly valued
Basic Materials
Price$10.39
Model IV$10.26
P/IV1.29
Premium +1% Return to IV: -1.3%
Owner yield 6.7% 10-yr IRR 11.1% · steady
Market implies +3.0%/yr vs model +4.5% · in line
KOP
Koppers Holdings Inc.
Deeply overvalued
Industrials
Price$45.61
Model IV$31.19
P/IV1.31
Premium +46% Return to IV: -31.6%
Owner yield 4.8% 10-yr IRR 5.9% · steady
Market implies +7.5%/yr vs model +3.8% · above model
LOW
LOWES COMPANIES INC
Deeply overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$190.98
Model IV$145.87
P/IV1.32
Premium +31% Return to IV: -23.6%
Owner yield 6.5% 10-yr IRR 7.4% · steady
Market implies +4.1%/yr vs model +0.5% · above model
SMG
SCOTTS MIRACLE-GRO CO
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$51.42
Model IV$44.21
P/IV1.33
Premium +16% Return to IV: -14.0%
Owner yield 14.3% 10-yr IRR 19.6% · steady
Market implies +0.2%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
IP
INTERNATIONAL PAPER CO /NEW/
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$35.33
Model IV$25.01
P/IV1.34
Premium +41% Return to IV: -29.2%
Owner yield 2.4% 10-yr IRR -1.7% · steady
Market implies +9.1%/yr vs model +5.1% · above model
UAL
United Airlines Holdings, Inc.
Deeply overvalued
Industrials
Price$114.39
Model IV$85.74
P/IV1.34
Premium +33% Return to IV: -25.0%
Owner yield 5.4% 10-yr IRR 10.8% · moderate
Market implies +11.2%/yr vs model +8.0% · above model
PHIN
PHINIA INC.
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$60.34
Model IV$57.48
P/IV1.34
Premium +5% Return to IV: -4.7%
Owner yield 6.8% 10-yr IRR 10.6% · steady
Market implies +3.9%/yr vs model +3.8% · in line
RYAM
RAYONIER ADVANCED MATERIALS INC.
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$8.48
Model IV$6.73
P/IV1.36
Premium +26% Return to IV: -20.6%
Market implies +5.1%/yr vs model +3.0% · in line
BRN
BARNWELL INDUSTRIES INC
Overvalued
Energy
Price$0.97
Model IV$0.75
P/IV1.39
Premium +29% Return to IV: -22.7%
Market implies -3.5%/yr vs model +0.0% · below model
BWA
BORGWARNER INC
Overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$63.32
Model IV$51.69
P/IV1.39
Premium +22% Return to IV: -18.4%
Owner yield 6.0% 10-yr IRR 10.5% · steady
Market implies +7.7%/yr vs model +5.9% · in line
TTE
TotalEnergies SE
Deeply overvalued
Energy
Price$90.06
Model IV$66.12
P/IV1.39
Premium +36% Return to IV: -26.6%
Owner yield 7.9% 10-yr IRR 10.4% · steady
Market implies +5.1%/yr vs model +0.8% · above model
VAC
MARRIOTT VACATIONS WORLDWIDE Corp
Deeply overvalued
Real Estate
Price$103.03
Model IV$59.20
P/IV1.43
Premium +74% Return to IV: -42.5%
Owner yield 2.2% 10-yr IRR -2.4% · steady
Market implies +13.0%/yr vs model +5.8% · above model
BLBD
Blue Bird Corp
Overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$58.64
Model IV$46.79
P/IV1.45
Premium +25% Return to IV: -20.2%
Owner yield 6.2% 10-yr IRR 12.8% · moderate
Market implies +9.6%/yr vs model +8.0% · in line
HD
HOME DEPOT, INC.
Deeply overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$297.20
Model IV$206.27
P/IV1.45
Premium +44% Return to IV: -30.6%
Owner yield 5.1% 10-yr IRR 6.8% · steady
Market implies +8.2%/yr vs model +3.9% · above model
EMN
EASTMAN CHEMICAL CO
Overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$65.09
Model IV$51.99
P/IV1.46
Premium +25% Return to IV: -20.1%
Owner yield 7.3% 10-yr IRR 8.7% · steady
Market implies +1.5%/yr vs model +0.0% · in line
NWSA
NEWS CORP
Deeply overvalued
Communication Services
Price$29.70
Model IV$17.74
P/IV1.47
Premium +67% Return to IV: -40.3%
Owner yield 3.0% 10-yr IRR -0.5% · steady
Market implies +9.4%/yr vs model +3.0% · above model
BCPC
BALCHEM CORP
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$167.34
Model IV$105.43
P/IV1.49
Premium +59% Return to IV: -37.0%
Market implies +10.9%/yr vs model +6.2% · above model
NGVT
Ingevity Corp
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$68.96
Model IV$45.26
P/IV1.50
Premium +52% Return to IV: -34.4%
Owner yield 5.6% 10-yr IRR 4.9% · steady
Market implies +4.4%/yr vs model +0.0% · above model
ASH
ASHLAND INC.
Deeply overvalued
Consumer Defensive
Price$69.06
Model IV$38.31
P/IV1.51
Premium +80% Return to IV: -44.5%
Owner yield 5.1% 10-yr IRR 3.7% · steady
Market implies +6.1%/yr vs model +0.0% · above model
CVGI
Commercial Vehicle Group, Inc.
Fairly valued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$2.99
Model IV$3.38
P/IV1.52
Discount 12% Return to IV: +13.1%
Owner yield 0.2% 10-yr IRR -27.7% · steady
Market implies -6.1%/yr vs model +0.0% · below model
WOR
WORTHINGTON ENTERPRISES, INC.
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$58.15
Model IV$37.07
P/IV1.53
Premium +57% Return to IV: -36.3%
Owner yield 10.3% 10-yr IRR 13.9% · steady
Market implies +4.2%/yr vs model +0.0% · above model
ALV
AUTOLIV INC
Deeply overvalued
Consumer Cyclical
Price$117.75
Model IV$82.01
P/IV1.55
Premium +44% Return to IV: -30.4%
Owner yield 5.9% 10-yr IRR 11.5% · moderate
Market implies +11.0%/yr vs model +7.4% · above model
BV
BrightView Holdings, Inc.
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$10.64
Model IV$7.97
P/IV1.55
Premium +33% Return to IV: -25.1%
Owner yield 7.3% 10-yr IRR 11.0% · steady
Market implies +5.7%/yr vs model +3.0% · in line
NYT
NEW YORK TIMES CO
Deeply overvalued
Communication Services
Price$70.53
Model IV$48.32
P/IV1.56
Premium +46% Return to IV: -31.5%
Owner yield 3.6% 10-yr IRR 5.4% · moderate
Market implies +11.1%/yr vs model +8.0% · above model
GURE
GULF RESOURCES, INC.
Fairly valued
Basic Materials
Price$3.29
Model IV$3.29
P/IV1.58
Premium +0% Return to IV: -0.2%
Market implies -6.7%/yr vs model +0.0% · below model
WDFC
WD 40 CO
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$191.54
Model IV$126.24
P/IV1.58
Premium +52% Return to IV: -34.1%
Owner yield 3.4% 10-yr IRR 2.8% · steady
Market implies +10.1%/yr vs model +5.8% · above model
XOM
EXXON MOBIL CORP
Deeply overvalued
Energy
Price$158.30
Model IV$104.62
P/IV1.59
Premium +51% Return to IV: -33.9%
Owner yield 4.3% 10-yr IRR 4.5% · steady
Market implies +9.1%/yr vs model +3.9% · above model
CVX
CHEVRON CORP
Deeply overvalued
Energy
Price$203.67
Model IV$132.76
P/IV1.61
Premium +53% Return to IV: -34.8%
Owner yield 4.5% 10-yr IRR 5.2% · steady
Market implies +9.3%/yr vs model +3.9% · above model
AVO
Mission Produce, Inc.
Deeply overvalued
Basic Materials
Price$12.80
Model IV$6.71
P/IV1.66
Premium +91% Return to IV: -47.6%
Market implies +13.6%/yr vs model +8.0% · above model